(If there's already a thread like this, please let me know and I'll have this deleted.)
I recently finished reading Sign of the Moon and want to hear what others think of it!
**WARNING: THERE MAY BE BIG SPOILERS AHEAD! READ ON WITH CAUTION!**
I honestly think that it was one of the more boring Warriors books I've read. I don't expect a big battle at the climax of each one, of course, but I want a little more than a couple of cats getting lost and Jayfeather/Jay's Wing "breaking up" with Half Moon.
What I'm about to say is basically my opinion of the plot, and as a result it's really really long. Feel free to skim over it and just reply with your own views of the book.
[hr]
[justify]The story begins when we find out that Stormfur and Brook settled down and had kits, and Stoneteller has lost faith in the Tribe of Endless Hunting. Does this remind you of Bluestar, anyone? Not much happening here other than establishing stuff that ends up being told anyway. After reading the book, I would have rather seen this section devoted to telling a little bit about the rogues who come along later on in the book, maybe saying why they insist on risking their lives and crossing the border. Oh well.
Moving on, it's time for Dovepaw and Ivypaw to become warriors. Dovepaw thoroughly fails in her assessment but she manages to pass because she saves Icecloud from falling in a hole. Isn't it heroic? Honestly, I don't think she deserved to pass. None of the not-part-of-the-Three cats know about her powers so how on earth do they explain how Dovepaw knew that Icecloud was about to fall? It feels very staged, as if Dovepaw went to Icecloud and said, "Hey, you fall into a hole, and I'll save you so I can pass!" Even if that seems OOC for Dovepaw, there's no other reason for the other cats to believe that she magically detected Icecloud's tumble. *sigh* I feel like Warriors has lost every scrap of its logic since the cats with MAJIKAL SUPERPOWAHS were born.
Anyway, the apprentices manage to pass. As I predicted (due to the prophecy, hello?) Dovepaw is named Dovewing. Ivypaw gets named Ivypool, which I suppose isn't a bad name. (Much better than Billystorm, but that's a different topic entirely.) Point is, they're both warriors because Icecloud took a tumble.
Lionblaze has come to the conclusion that Icecloud fell in the same tunnels that his sister ran into, and after he tells Jayfeather the blind medicine cat insists they go looking for Hollyleaf's body--which he apparently thought wouldn't disturb him if they succeeded. By now I think that most of the fanbase has the feeling that Hollyleaf lives on, so it's no surprise when they decide that she's alive.
Ivypool visits the Dark Forest again and talks to Tigerheart. No matter what he meant to do I've always thought that he's a big moron for thinking that he and Dovewing could ever be together and insisting they can break the warrior code. But anyway, the rest of her visit goes on smoothly enough (as far as the Dark Forest's version of "smooth" is concerned) and the old spirit Mapleshade--StarClan knows how her spirit hasn't vanished, considering that there probably aren't many living cats who remember her--thinks that Ivypool is loyal. Riight....
Skipping forward a few days, Dovewing attends a Gathering with her Clan. This chapter is really just a bunch of shipping (Dove/Bumble, Dove/Tiger, and possibly Grass/Briar) so I won't go into it much.
Jayfeather is soon summoned to the mountains, and after he tells Firestar he gets Squirrelflight, Foxleap, and Dovewing on his tail. Honestly, I thought that there would be a bit more conflict between him and his mother before he drifted off to the past, and was a bit disappointed to see that there weren't any big arguments along the way. Later on he sees Yellowfang, who warns him that he shouldn't be going on this journey (although it seems that they return just fine). Also, Ashfur had issues with loving too much. Yeeahhh....
Lionblaze and Cinderheart hunt together and talk about what isn't in their future. Leafpool comes along after the reincarnated medicine cat runs away and tells her son that she probably still loves him... as if that's not obvious. Hm. Maybe Lionblaze is more dense than I thought....
Meanwhile, during the journey to the mountains, Antpelt dies of his injuries. Sad, I suppose, but later on when Ivypool finds him willingly in the Dark Forest every shred of sympathy you might have felt is gone with the wind. While she's on another spy/training mission, we find that Blossomfall is in the Dark Forest as well, obviously because she wants to get her mouse-brained mother's attention (though that's not "revealed" until later on). That's it, Blossomfall, turn your back on your mother and KILL HER!!! *coughs* Ahem....
Jayfeather's/Squirrelflight's patrol arrives at the Tribe of Rushing Water. Stoneteller is obviously not happy to see them but allows them to stay. Dovewing finds that there are rogues crossing the Tribe's border and talks to Jayfeather about their destiny. Oh yeah, and Stoneteller is a shell of his former self (much like Bluestar again, yes?) and has refused to decide on a cat to take his place when he dies.
Next, Lionblaze and his patrol get attacked by dogs, but the mutts are so obedient that they return to their owners at one call. There's a little more Lion/Cinder before the story moves on. So far there hasn't been anything going on that's really interesting and we're already, what, halfway through the book?
Finally something interesting happens when Jayfeather is thrown back to the past as Jay's Wing, where we see some Jay/Moon (which sounds better than Jay/Half, even if the later makes more since).
Then, before Jay's story can continue, we go back to the Clans to find that Ivypool and Blossomfall get lost in the tunnels. Blossomfall admits the truth that we've likely known from the very beginning: that she's been visiting the Dark Forest because Millie's being a terrible mother. No surprise there. Also not overly surprising is the fact that Fallen Leaves (come on, Erin, it's kinda obvious) and likely Hollyleaf help lead them out. Rather than get a warm welcome when they return to their Clan with the worst excuse possible, Millie snaps at her daughter because she's apparently forgotten that Briarlight isn't the only cat in the Clan. Graystripe, where the heck are you in this book to set your mate straight?
Meanwhile, in the past, Jay really doesn't want to leave but Rock tells him otherwise. For some reason he listens to the old coot and admits everything to Half Moon, who is obviously upset. Shy Fawn has her kits (unlike Whitewing, who you may recall was "about to kit" for moons before the finally did) and Jay realizes that the Three are all in the past (because the fact that there was a Dove and a Jay didn't give it away). Half Moon gets over her initial shock, Jay names her the Tribe's first Healer, and leaves. Wait, was that (and the bumbling mouse-brains getting lost) supposed to be the climax?
Back to the present, Dovewing insists that the Tribe helps the rogues because they think that the rogues will "owe them" if they save Flora's pelt. Instead, Swoop dies because Foxleap is an impatient squirrel-head. Rather than join the Tribe and blame him, Dovewing defends the older warrior by saying that they could have lost the rogue instead. *facepalm* Those rogues had better hunt for the Tribe every single day after that.
Not surprisingly, the Tribe seems more than happy to be rid of the Clan cats, and the book ends with Stoneteller dying (why couldn't it have been Loserblaze or that kittypet?), Jayfeather thinking that he suddenly has the right to name Crag the Tribe's new Healer, and Half Moon saying that she will wait for her futuristic boyfriend forever.[/justify]
[hr]
Yes, that sounded like a giant rant. Honestly, I feel like the only reason I read these books anymore is for the lulz/because I want to see Millie die. Hollyleaf really needs to come back, be her crazy self, and show these cats who's boss.